Thursday, 31 May 2012

Contextualizing Indigenous Education: Where does knowledge come from? What are the methods for teaching and the ways of transmitting knowledge?

Part II: Common Rituals as Part of Ongoing Lifetime Education and Well-Being of the Community
It is through the various rituals that we realize the essence of holistic pedagogy since they not only enhanced the learning experience for youth but were intended to reinforce the health and collective welfare of the community and simultaneously revitalize the integration of spirit, mind, and body of the individual in relation to family, kin, community, universe, and the Creator.

The Powwow is still a theme today and represents a great celebration of life with reverence and gratitude to all creatures and the Creator.  Other traditions "smudging", has the participant waft the smoke from sweet grass/sage/cedar upward as to inhale, intended as a purifying or cleansing ritual. Similarly, yet more intense, the sweat lodges which are comparable to saunas are used for meditation and cleansing the body, mind, and soul.  And how can we forget the Medicine Wheel which most Native Americans still practice today.  While there are various versions and methods employed, generally the ceremony begins with an opening prayer, where after, the individual starts at the symbolic inner circle of the wheel and undergoes a process of reflection in attempt to face and overcome inner struggles.  From there, the individual moves outward to other circles of knowledge, from kin to community, environment, society, the universe, and the Great Spirit or Creator.  In effect, one gains a sense of place within the larger whole.  Unlike the other ceremonial methods, Tipi Teachings is perhaps more in line with conventional non-Aboriginal approaches to instruction where 15 principles or values are reiterated and there is expectation that the learner will adopt these in their encounters with others and the larger world.  

 

Although Part I and Part II of this commentary is an attempt to contextualize traditional Indigenous pedagogy and epistemology, it only touches briefly on key aspects.  Therefore, it is important to keep in mind the rich cultural heritage to which no amount of writing could do justice.  Sadly, it is this heritage that was almost lost during the colonization period where the Indigenous were forced to surrender their "ways of knowing” and instead adopt the Eurocentric pedagogy.  In an upcoming entry or note, I would like to explore this somewhat, once again as an attempt to contextualize the Indigenous experience and the importance of culturally-relevant education. 

Contextualizing Indigenous Education: Where does knowledge come from? What are the methods for teaching and the ways of transmitting knowledge?

Part I: The Knowledge Systems Prior to Contact With Europeans What comes to mind when we raise the topic “Indigenous Education"? The only way we can truly grasp the full meaning of this is to put the concept in its social, economic, and historic context.  Prior to contact with Europeans, the Indigenous peoples did actually have systems of knowledge (education) already established.  However, the Europeans didn't recognize these systems as "educative" but instead perceived many of the methods as "uncivilized” or "primitive" rituals.   According to Jeannette Armstrong, the Indigenous learning experience was a continual process and was integrated with everyday experiences where individuals interacted with kin, family, elders, peers, the community, the environment, and the universe (Creator)

Armstrong, J. (1987). Traditional Indigenous education: A natural process.

The knowledge, therefore, originated from the individual's experience and interaction with all interrelated aspects of culture from parents to elders to environment to rituals.  As such, it cannot be viewed as a linear process but rather is circular and dialectic.

To begin with, parents and elders did play a key role in transmitting knowledge.  Similar to how parents motivate their children in non-Aboriginal contexts, the Indigenous parent and grandparents were influential in showing pride or encouraging their children wherever they demonstrated cooperative behavior that contributed to the welfare of the whole community.  Interestingly enough, various approaches used for children and youth resonate with cognitive themes.  This was demonstrated in recognition of various stages of development that a learner undergoes and must achieve prior to moving onto to the next learning phase.  The methods, however, departed significantly from the conventional Eurocentric approaches.  For instance, the entire community, along with various rituals, were involved in assisting the youth through the challenges of development.  Rituals, as puberty rites, would be an example of this.  Where one passed from adolescence to adulthood, the custom known as "vision quest" was more of an individual journey into the wilderness accompanied by guidance from the spirit world until a "vision" of significance would be conveyed.  Upon arrival back to the community, the individual was highly revered and expected to share his/her vision with everyone, thus imparting the experience and newly learned knowledge to the collective whole.  Other examples, included more recreational and outdoor activities that occurred early in the day while relaxation, meditation, sharing circles, story-telling, and even crafting, were more suitable for night as to be in sync with the natural rhythm of the universe. 
During the day, children and adolescents were guided by parents, elders, and other members of the community to actively experience the outdoor practices of survival, including hunting skills and gathering of herbs, berries etc.  In addition, they learned first-hand how to respect and yet make use of other resources from nature.  This was informal but it exposed the learner to the authentic environment.  Furthermore, there were instructions on how to use resources to make shelters, tools, crafts, clothing, etc....  But once again, the methods departed from Eurocentric approaches since much was transmitted orally and made meaningful and sacred through "story-telling” and reliance on legends.  Moreover, significant customs, rituals, and ceremonies were involved to give greater affirmation to ongoing learning throughout one's entire life.  Thus education is not fixed and static or reserved only for youth but is realized as dynamic, fluid, and adaptive. 

Wednesday, 30 May 2012

First Nations Holistic Lifelong Learning Model

The First Nations Holistic Lifelong Learning Model is part of an ongoing initiative—Redefining how Success is Measured in Aboriginal Learning—of the Canadian Council on Learning (CCL) and its Aboriginal Learning Knowledge Centre, and First Nations, Inuit and Métis organizations.

The objective of this initiative is to develop the tools needed to more accurately measure learning progress for Aboriginal people through the application of a comprehensive framework—the three Holistic Lifelong Learning Models. The models are living documents that explore the learning processes and purposes of First Nations, Inuit and Métis, and are intended as “starting points” that can be adapted to communities needs.

The First Nations Holistic Lifelong Learning Modelis a result of ongoing discussions among First Nations learning professionals, community practitioners, researchers and analysts.

The First Nations Holistic Lifelong Learning Model uses a stylized graphic to convey the dynamic processes and relationships that characterize learning First Nations communities. The image attests to the cyclical, regenerative power of holistic lifelong learning and its relationship to community well-being.

http://www.ccl-cca.ca/pdfs/RedefiningSuccess/CCL_Learning_Model_FN.pdf

Tuesday, 29 May 2012

Use of Technology for Indigenous Pedagogy and Epistemology; Constructivist Argument


Since the period of colonization in North America, the Indigenous peoples were often subject to investigative reports and research conducted on behalf of colonial authorities and later the government, as well as, academia that followed empirical standards of the scientific model. However, with increasing number of Aboriginals acquiring post-secondary education, skepticism has emerged as to the Eurocentric bias of data collected on Canada's Indigenous and Metis peoples. The stark contrast between cultures helped sharpen this skeptical inquiry where revival of a distinctive Aboriginal epistemology and pedagogy has emerged as a credible alternative to the presumed objectivism of mainstream academia.

For instance, traditional epistemology is based on a holistic approach where the individual is viewed as interconnected within a web of interactions that include integrated mind, body, and spirit in relation to others, community, environment, and the universe. Given this cultural context, elders, healers, spiritual traditions, rituals, oral story-telling, and interaction with environment are key to acquiring and transmitting knowledge. Since this type of knowledge emphasizes meaningful interpretations from the 'standpoint' of the 'knower', the epistemology draws upon qualitative dimensions not easily codified or measured according to strict scientific standards. Furthermore, there is social interest in using such knowledge to the benefit & well-being of the Indigenous and Aboriginal peoples as well as the larger community (praxis). Research that is founded on these epistemological principles therefore can serve to collect qualitative data, offer interpretive meaning, and raise awareness as to Indigenous issues. In this respect, holistic can be incorporated into conventional science, but moreover, the Eurocentric bias at all levels of education, should be re-assessed & subject to critical inquiry. Postmodern constructivism is most adept at this. With this background in mind, the question also arises as to whether or not technological tools used to compile, code, quantify data would compromise holistic ethics (audio/video recordings, computer programs, etc.). For instance, is it possible to maintain the integrity of "oral story telling" if this is transferred and stored in print on the computer where it will be further interpreted and categorized? Will this violate the cultural meaning and the ethics of the Aboriginal community? Or are there strategies and ways by which to counter these possible threats, as community-based research, one holistic methodology would imply? Moreover, could various technological devices actually contribute to and enrich the holistic approach to research and learning? (e.g. use of the internet to connect with other Indigenous peoples & also to share knowledge and raise awareness with the larger global community).