An Examination of Holistic Learning and Technology
Examining the implications of technology when applied to Indigenous Pedagogy and Epistemology.
Tuesday, 19 June 2012
Can the Internet promote multiple ways of knowing or is there a danger that Globalization will subsume diversity, along with Indigenous Pedagogy?
A Vision of K-12 Students Today:"this project was created to inspire teachers" to use technology in a collaborative, engaging, and motivational way as to be learner-centered. Ipads, computer games, emails, blogs, wikis, podcasts, and digital story-telling are all displayed as tools, in this respect. Indeed, there are many possibilities upon tapping into these resources to help weave Indigenous pedagogy into curricular activities, as mentioned in earlier posts. However, the general idea still needs to be worked out and broken down into more detailed analysis when it comes to the issue of diversity and creating multiple perspectives. As such, we must be cautious about how these programs are applied, especially in a globalized context where multiplicity and diversity may face risk of being subsumed under the weight of a homogenous climate promoted by search engines as Google, Bing, etc...Or certain sites that are tailored to fit the Western/Eurocentric agenda. What prompted me to speculate on this was the part in the video where there is implication that technology encourages use of "English" as the main language, assuming this should be understood and preserved as universal medium. Meanwhile, I witness Indigenous communities struggling to preserve what is left of their culture and, especially their language. The importance of technology is evermore being recognized as a tool and means of fulfilling this dream. Consequently, it should not be assumed that it is desirable to use technology in such a way as to undermine diversity via goals for a more homogenous world. Rather, I see hope in using innovations to promote multiple "knowledge" and "learning systems". Subsequently, at a micro level, educational innovations can go a far way in promoting multiple perspectives alongside collaborative efforts. This can be applied further to the macro level where applying technology in this manner can contribute to a provocative, rich, and much broader understanding of all diverse peoples across the globe. Imagine the possibilities! In a sense, we could view the collaborative and multiple-perspective protocol of educational technology as a model for world efforts at unity, sustainability, and even peace.
Wednesday, 13 June 2012
Incorporating Indigenous themes with use of technological innovations
A few months ago, I had attended a conference where the central theme evolved around strategies by which to incorporate Aboriginal "ways of knowing" and "teaching” into all levels of contemporary academics. Most guest speakers observed the various barriers ranging from Eurocentric bias to reluctance by administrators and/or educational staff to adopt new initiatives that would require change and effort. Given this resistance, many Aboriginal scholars have taken up the challenge themselves to design practical methods by which to make the changes toward integrated pedagogies readily accessible and easy to implement.
Wade Houle was exemplary in this respect since he has developed concrete step by step instructions, guides, rubrics, and lesson plans for K-12 teachers,instructors, and staff. Although there is a common thread that draws upon Aboriginal themes, Houle presents methods that prompt and elicit a wide array of skills that apply universally to all students. As such, he recommends that curricular assignments make use of multiple mediums by which to elicit visualization, dreaming, playing, interacting, reflexivity, reading, writing, empathy, drawing, painting, storytelling, and ecological sensitivity. Moreover, he encourages appropriate use of technology that nicely demonstrates how Indigenous pedagogy can quite readily be adapted to fit with new directions in mainstream education, itself. For example, “Google search" strategies are required for many research activities where, in one instance, the student pairs with another to investigate and then profile the similarities and differences between a real town and a real First Nation reservation with comparable population size.
The above activities offer demonstrations of general uses of technology; but Houle does encourage more specific creative applications as observed in the following tasks: (1) "You will create a Facebook page for one of the characters involved in the novel The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Make the page a replica to Facebook but choose to create walls, status, photos, notes, friends, links, chats, pokes & conversations about the book: character, setting,plot" (2) Create a "video blog.....a short (4-5 min) video in a newscast style format. Use a desk and different symbols to [represent] a news broadcast [based on information you have garnered].... from The Oka Standoff of 1990.
On a more playful note, Houle too includes curriculum activities that are more appropriate for younger learners such as the "Tic-Tac-Toe Board". This method is ideal for allowing creative options as it encourages use of multiple mediums and the game format gives added incentive to children. Here, the student is required to choose projects from the tic-tac-toe board as to form a line of 3 activities and coordinate these into one complete project (e.g. i. write a dialogue as if it is two people from a text with Aboriginal theme, ii. create flash cards from a given topic, iii. podcast the scene from the text, video record with phone- video and/or radio podcasts). (Wade Houle: AWASIS conference package)
Reflecting upon the practical lesson plans offered by Houle, I was impressed with how he incorporated Indigenous themes into curriculum; but even moreso, was inspired by use of technological innovations as a means of making this objective all the more possible. Furthermore, I find the synthesis of holistics with technology as most promising when applied in such a manner as to have students interact with each other in mixed settings. The common denominator in this case IS TECHNOLOGY especially where podcasts, facebook simulations, etc are used to facilitate empathy for characters from different contexts, vantage points, and multiple perspectives.
Saturday, 9 June 2012
The Power of Mobile Devices:
Using the IPad in classrooms is an innovation that more schools are adopting. While beneficial for all students, it too can offer opportunity to integrate Indigenous Pedagogy into curricular activities. As this video suggests, there already is a program in the works entitled "Digital Natives". This allows the learner to make graphics, images, and pictures that can further be uploaded to the Utube. One instance, here, demonstrates how a student uses the IPad to learn about Native traditions as "sewing" and "stitching" so she can further compile the information together in a video. This raises numerous implications for addressing various Indigenous themes from the standpoint of Aboriginals via creative technological devices that can use vocals, images, music, etc as to create emotive effect and simultaneously contextualize Native experience and teachings.
Best IPad Utility Apps for Schools:
This video demonstrates the 5 key apps most suitable for teachers and students in the classroom. While considering each of these, it is notable how the apps can be useful to the Indigenous learner who has opportunity to express their culture, ancestral roots, and identity through these sources. The I Thought HD and the Evernote apps are perhaps the most suitable in this respect. The I Thought HD offers the student an array of options to adjust and make changes to the imagery which then can be used to make videos pictographs etc. Meanwhile, the Evernote allows one to use video and voice apps for connecting to the IPad or other devices. Essentially, then this medium encourages Indigenous students to offer perspectives from their own vantage point and likely will bring in cultural elements and themes that can be shared with other classmates.
Thursday, 7 June 2012
Pixton for Schools: Web-Based Comics. Web-comics is another innovation that is increasingly being used in classrooms particularly at the elementary levels where it appears most suitable for the younger learners. Through these programs as Pixton, students are encouraged to design their own characters, speech bubbles, layouts, props, and settings as a means to express themselves through use of "story-telling". While one can see the many advantages this program offers to all students insofar it fosters learner-centred creativity and opportunity to convey ideas, thoughts,& emotions from one's own vantage point, it is ideal when in the hands of the Indigenous student. This is because, the Indigenous learner is equipped with the tools to use various mediums by which to contextualize their "oral tradition",drawing upon themes unique to their culture. If we take this a step further,from the individual level to sharing this with a group of students in collaborative efforts, some problems may arise in mixed settings. For instance,the web-comics allow students to have conversations with each other by inserting dialogue into the empty bubble space. Yet this runs the risk of students making disrespectful or hostile remarks to fellow learners. Nonetheless,there is a way to bypass this risk. Students first set up their own individual comic designs, then submit these to the teacher,whereupon approval, they will be shared with the rest of the class for collaboration. It then is left in the hands of the teacher to monitor the activity closely and ensure respectful behavior and openness to diversity. One key question arises here - how accountable will teachers be in monitoring this activity? Will this require re-defining the role of the teacher's responsibility to counter prejudice within the classroom? or is this already an issue, regardless of technology?
Wednesday, 6 June 2012
Technology as a Tool or a Barrier To Indigenous Pedagogy in the Classroom? A Few Points to Ponder...
As mentioned in an earlier post, Driscoll's review of
various technological tools to be used in the classroom prompted ideas about how simulated settings,
as Goal-Based Scenarios (GBS) and Problem-Based Learning (PBL), could prove
promising for incorporating Indigenous themes into the curriculum (Psychology
for Learning Instruction. 2005, p. 404-405). This is not to say that there may be obstacles
in way of implementing these collaborative programs especially in mixed
settings where diverse ideas might not be embraced by all students or
parents. This is where the role of the
teacher comes in to ensure the programs facilitate cooperation, respect, and
trust. In addition, the instructor may
have to monitor and guide these virtual settings as to ensure the process of
collaboration is being carried out as planned.
Moreover, the virtual programs to be used should be carefully
selected. Prior to using these programs,
the learners could be offered guidelines adapted from Tipi Teachings, for
instance (Mary Lee Sutherland, Tipi Teachings: AWASIS conference 2012).
Other issues, however, must also be considered when using
these microworlds and hypermedia: how appropriate are these programs for
younger children? does age make a difference? (these issues apply regardless of
ethnicity of the learners involved).
Both Holistic and Cognitive theorists do converge in this respect,
especially if we consider that learning is developmental according to
stages. The K-3 student, for instance,
is more likely to manage concrete concepts and ideas while the more mature
learner is capable of abstract thinking.
In addition, many of these collaborative models do require higher level
age-appropriate metacognitive skills and self-regulatory motivation (Driscoll,
p. 401). Nonetheless, there are other
virtual programs that exist which are more suitable for children and could be
useful also to introduce holistic themes.
This is particularly true of programs that can easily be
adapted to fit the learner's level of development. For instance, software shells that make use
of "Bubble Dialogue" allows "students to create conversations
among comic strip characters, including thoughts that would not be said out
loud", in other formats (Driscoll, p. 405).
The advantages of the Bubble Dialogue resides in it's suitability for
younger children as well as it's ability to encourage multiple perspectives
through open conversation. In this way,
comic characters could be designed to represent peoples of various ethnicities,
including Aboriginals. As well, prompts
and cues could be embedded as to create context and inspire themes relevant to
Indigenous or Holistic perspectives. For
instance, the setting of the comic strip could display an environment in which
a Pow Wow ceremony can be seen in the background. Even so, as I am writing this, it occurs to
me that given this is a fabricated setting, problems of the design may run the
risk of being stereotypical. Would the
designer have to be Aboriginal in order to avoid the risk of producing
stereotypical images of Indigenous people and settings? or would there be a
risk of stereotyping regardless of who designs the program? These are obviously
questions that need to be considered especially since the goal is one in which
we want to build bridges of understanding, rather than set the stage for
divisiveness.Tuesday, 5 June 2012
Using Tipi Teachings in The Classroom To Overcome Technological Obstacles:
Much value can be
found in using collaborative based technology in classrooms since simulated environments
can be posed to allow students to work together as a team and contribute their
own unique skills to either problem-based or goal-based scenarios. A challenge may arise, however, where
teammates are not open to diversity or multiple perspectives. Other issues of concern are evident where a
particular techno format itself fosters competition instead of cooperation. Consequently, there is a role for the
instructor to play in acting as a guide or a coach and providing simulated
contexts and prompts that encourage collaboration and respect for diverse
perspectives. This too would be
excellent opportunity to introduce the 15 principles of Tipi Teachings as to
overcome the barriers and facilitate an environment based on mutual respect and
trust. Within such an environment,
learners will likely feel more comfortable in expressing their own unique ideas
and simultaneously will be encouraged to re-think different perspectives and
adapt this to prior knowledge. While
this could prove a valuable preamble to working together in simulated techno
-generated settings, it too could apply to the real world. Nonetheless, the emphasis given to respect
for all others is a reminder to the "virtual learner” that s/he is dealing
with real people in real-life.
Happiness: Happiness is connected with a healthy spirit and balance. When we understand we are related to all things, there is happiness.
An elaboration on
the Tipi Teachings, itself, sets out principles that are valuable to all
learning communities and illustrates quite nicely how these concepts can set
the context for a hospitable and collaborative setting:
Respect: We must give
honour to our elders and fellow teachers and students and the strangers that
come to visit our community. We must
honour other people's basic rights and beliefs.
Obedience: We learn by
listening to traditional stories; by listening to our parents or guardians, our
fellow students and our teachers. We
learn by their behaviors and their reminders, so that we know what is right and
what is wrong.
Humility: We are not above
or below others in the circle of life.
We feel humbled when we understand our relationship with
creation....."We are a strand in a web of life" and we respect and
value lifeHappiness: Happiness is connected with a healthy spirit and balance. When we understand we are related to all things, there is happiness.
Love: If we are to live in harmony we
must accept one another as we are and to accept others who are not in our
circle. Love means to be kind and good
to one another.
Faith: We must learn to believe and trust
others, to believe in a power greater than ourselves. That gives us strength to be worthy members
of the human race.
Kinship: [Love and
respect for kin].....This includes [parents, sisters, brothers, cousins,
relatives, grandparents, and all others who] love us and give us roots......and
a sense of belonging to a community
Cleanliness: We must learn
not to inflict ill on others.....Good habits reflect a clean mind [attitude
toward others]
Thankfulness:We learn to give
thanks for all the kind things others do for us....
Sharing:We learn to be
part of the family [community] by helping in providing food or other basic needs
[and resources]. This is sharing
responsibilities in order to enjoy them.
Strength:We must learn to
be patient in times of trouble....to endure and show understanding. We must accept difficulties...so that we
may give others strength to accept their own difficulties and tragedies.
Good Child-Rearing: Children are [to
be treated as] unique and blessed with the gift of life....We are responsible
for their well-being, spiritually, emotionally, physically and for their
intellectual development.....
Hope: We must hope for
better things to make life easier for [all] of us....
Ultimate Protection: "health for
a balanced caring for body, mind, emotions and the spirit of the individual,
the family, the community and the nation."
Control Flaps: We are all
connected by relationships and we depend on each other for balance. This controls and creates harmony in the
circle of life. [note that the control
flaps represent the flaps at the top of the tipi and help to bind these 15
poles together in one whole] -adapted from Mary Lee Sutherland, Tipi
Teachings: AWASIS conference
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)