I will draw much on M.
Driscoll's analysis for this one because I believe she provides an excellent
overview of technological mediums (Driscoll: Psychology of Learning for
Instruction). To start with,
"microworlds" are similar to interactive simulations but use a system
suitable to the learner (p. 403). As such,
Aboriginal students could interact from the vantage point of their cultural
reality and simultaneously use the event to construct and deconstruct the event
in a way that is validating and empowering of Indigenous identity and
values. The same holds true regarding “hypermedia
designs" that offer graphics, descriptions, research data, definitions,
autobiographical information, etc..(p. 403)
Here, the learner is open to a wide array of data bases that they can
choose to appropriate into their inquiry of a hypothetical situation. Because this is learner-centred activity that
focuses on authentic experience from the perspective of the learner, it allows
for Indigenous cultural context to be re-invented and affirmed in the
process.
As with microworlds and
hypermedia, Goal-Based Scenarios (GBS) and Problem-Based Learning (PBL), too
involve techno-generated simulations; but, have the added benefit of allowing
the learner to work with a group or team through collaboration (p. 404-405). This then, does have different implications
than posed by the self-regulating simulations, since the Aboriginal "learner"
set in a group context, may feel marginalized in the everyday world due to
different social conditions, ethnicity, and cultural context. Consequently, the need to collaborate in a
simulated environment could be either inhibiting or facilitating depending on
the approach used by other teammates. On the other hand, this format could offer excellent opportunity for
exchange of multiple perspectives where it is anticipated that the concept
"collaboration” not only appreciates diverse views but relies on variety
and coordination of efforts in order to elicit most meaningful and positive
outcomes.
For instance, in PBL, the team
is presented with a simulated environment where they must each contribute their
own suggestions as to how best to resolve a complex or "touchy"
problem. Say the challenge posed is to
prevent someone from attempting suicide.
This is a real life situation that many people may never had to
experience firsthand. However, in the
Aboriginal community, suicide rates are disproportionately high when compared
to the non-Aboriginal counterparts (this holds true for people in other
marginalized groups). As such, the
perspective offered by the Aboriginal learner, may be most helpful in offering
contextual understanding, as well as, some holistic approaches regarding
"healing" aimed at reflexive thought to confront and overcome
struggles in such a way to empower the troubled individual. From there, more ideas could be generated by
fellow teammates, and in these ideas, the Aboriginal student may very well
learn of other options that were not considered before. Similarly, the same opportunities arise with
use of GBS techno-scenarios, with the only difference residing in collaborative
efforts used to address a specific goal.
As an example, the instructor could set a concrete goal where learners
are expected to work together and make a "make a tipi" using techno
graphics. Throughout the process, it
would be even more challenging to request that the students adhere to the 15
tipi teachings as they construct their ideas and designs in collaboration with
each other.
Driscoll also refers to a
software shell called the STAR LEGACY to facilitate "adaptive learning
environments", to test “one's understanding, and .... [to have] learners
publish the results of their thinking for others to consider" (p. 405). The advantage of this program is obvious in
respect to allowing and encouraging the Indigenous learner to offer
perspectives and ideas from their cultural vantage point. Furthermore, it too affords opportunity for
multiple and alternative perspectives to adapt to holistics or where holistics
can be adapted to fit with other views.
This would involve and/or require "juxtaposition" of ideas
where various themes and relationships are drawn out so that the Indigenous voice
is weaved into a whole new paradigm.
These above strategies are
merely a starting point because they give a more general overview of some
viable approaches. However, there is
need to explore this in more concrete terms when used as "lesson plans"
for instruction. An upcoming post shall
pursue this further.
I think you're making an important observation about PBL and other collaborative approaches to teaching and learning. The success of any group activity depends on trust, and that implies a measure of mutuality and shared awareness and intentions. These fundamental respect issues will no doubt determine whether these kinds of strategies will be successful in a mixed learning environment.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if some of the teachings of in Indigenous ed, and particularly the 15 tipi teachings can provide advice on how to overcome this challenge?
Great insight and an excellent question! Actually I am in the process of preparing a post on this very topic. Its almost completed and I will post shortly. Thanks Again!
ReplyDelete