Some of the
earliest Indigenous research models arose out of awareness that European
researchers of the past compiled information in such a way as to
de-contextualize and distort the actual lives and experiences of the subjects
under investigation. The pretense of
objectivity was exposed by skeptical Indigenous scholars who identified
ethnographic descriptions of Aboriginals as based on "value-laden" judgments
that portrayed the subjects as primitive peoples. Data therefore was neither reliable nor
credible. With this in mind, the
skeptics of conventional scientific research saw an urgency to adopt new
guidelines, methodologies, and ethics where and when the research was applied
to Indigenous communities (Kovach, M. 2009, Indigenous Methodologies). However, it is notable that from these
protocols, scholars saw utility in further developing these principles into a
distinctive model for research design and application to be accepted as
credible and legitimate for all fields of study regardless the subject under
inquiry.
One model that is exemplary and has most
frequently been used is known as Community-Based Participatory Research
(CBPR). According to Verna St.Denis this
model departs from the conventional Western-based scientific model because the
subjects of the research become active participants in the research
itself. Key differences of the
Indigenous Methodology or CBPR can be summarized as the following: ( i) it
is transformative, purposive, and proactive to result in empowering and
improving lives of the subjects (ii) it is based on equality, collaboration,
sharing between the researcher and the subjects, (iii) the subjects have access
to & and are encouraged to interact with the data by offering their own
insights and theories (iv) the findings should be made available to the
subjects before being published (Native Studies Review 8, #2, 1992).Although this model is most admirable in respecting the cultural context and integrity of the subjects, there still remains the problem of how to compile data and transfer it to print in a way that respects the "oral tradition" of the Indigenous. This becomes more apparent when data collection is based primarily on conversation, narratives, unstructured/structured interviews, sharing circles, journaling etc... Moreover, Margaret Kovach suggests that with conventional scientific models too much emphasis is placed on fragmenting data collection as to result in categories of conceptual frameworks and coding. Consequently, there is risk of de-contextualizing the holistic experience and process of the subjects. Nonetheless, she does suggest there are ways to counter this using a "specific knowledge gathering method" that organizes data around themes in such a way that the process stays true to the narrative. (Kovach, 2009).
It is here that the question arises as to the use of technology in respect to holistic research methods. In regard to storing of data, electronic programs to transfer the collected information into workable and manageable data processing, the ethnograph program appears most suitable since it allows the data to be stored as a whole yet with the option of retrieving segments through formatting, copying, pasting (McMillan, J.H. & Schumacher, S. Research in Education. 2010). This would be particularly useful where and when a certain theme of priority is to be addressed, reviewed, until the meaning is agreed upon and given approval by participants. However, there are other viable uses for technology to be applied in the collection of data itself. Given the various means to be considered in this respect, as well as the ensuing pros and cons, the topic shall be discussed under a separate heading in part II
No comments:
Post a Comment