Monday, 4 June 2012

Indigenous Pedagogy and Epistemology in Research:Implications for Applying

Part II:  Applying Technology to Holistic Methods
Because holistic data collection relies primarily on story-telling, dialogue, group discussions, personal journals, interviews, and situational settings of the participants; technology can be used in various ways to contextualize and maintain the authenticity and integrity of the subjects. In fact, if one delves into this further, we find that the Community Based Participatory Research has accorded different technological tools as most effective means to guide the process of data collection. Initially, this was observed early on where the researcher would video tape group sharing circles, interviews, interactions, conversations, and story-telling.  This, of course, required the consent of the participants. The pros and cons of using technology in this way, however, are obvious when we consider the possibility that the participant who is conscious of being technologically observed may feel inhibited or compelled to respond in a less authentic manner.  Furthermore, it could be viewed as an intrusive measure since the technology, in the hands of the researcher, puts the subject under a microscope. 

Another more promising initiative resides in the use of "photovoice", a method that combines photography, video, and auditory tools that are to be controlled by the participants themselves. There are many advantages to using this technique since it is versatile and allows the participant to convey their stories, experiences, vantage point, and even situational context through mediums in which they feel most comfortable.  One variation makes use of "digital story-telling" where the research subjects themselves create visuals and vocals to convey their narratives and situational experiences.  Two other technological devices known as "paint voice” and "comic voice" are perhaps more appropriate where the research subject are children.  Comic voice or webcomics, for example, are similar to bubble comics that are taken from internet sites and used to elicit responses in the form of narratives and dialogues.  Not only is this interactive but it has a playful dimension that likely would appeal to children in anticipation that they will respond authentically and with relative ease.  In respect to "paintvoice", this also is a tool in the hands of the participant who uses the computer to create art projects as another means of conveying their stories by creating visual graphics which reflect their situational context and experiences.    

Ultimately, this theme holds out much promise and raises many creative ideas and prospects, especially in this age of the internet. So we must not stop analyses here, just yet. Future posts shall explore this further. Finally, I would like to emphasize another key issue that draws upon the importance of using the internet as a tool to raise awareness to others regarding Indigenous Experience.  We must not forget this since it is an important aspect of holistic pedagogy and research - the idea of praxis and the transformative goal of improving the conditions of and empowering the lives of Aboriginals, while interacting with Indigenous across the globe, who have for far too long been marginalized from political and academic discourse.   

http://www.mendeley.com/research/modifying-photovoice-communitybased-participatory-indigenous-research/

1 comment:

  1. Yes, I think you touched on the most important drawback of using any technology for recording interview data -- it almost naturally intrudes and the conversation is changed. In research terms, it introduces a particular type of bias.

    Interesting that you found "photo voice" and see that it may reduce this effect.

    There are also methodological ways to reduce the intrusive effect of technology. For example, introducing the technology into the environment and using it for several interviews prior to doing the actual research interviews can relax the participant and, in effect, make the technology much less apparent. Also, using smaller devices and even placing them behind large objects can help participants ignore them.

    But in the end, I agree completely, that the goal is to make the technology disappear.

    ReplyDelete